A specialist HIV pharmacist has been suspended for nine months after she expressed “profound regret” for accessing a hospital patient’s medical records without clinical justification and then using a junior colleague’s login details to attempt to disguise her actions.
Fiona Clark, formerly a senior lead pharmacist at Cardiff and Vale University Health Board, accessed the patient’s digital medical record on five dates between July 2017 and September 2023, the General Pharmaceutical Council’s (GPhC) fitness to practise committee found following a two-day videolink hearing that concluded on November 12.
When her actions came to the attention of the health board’s governance team, she denied having access the patient’s records and said it could have been a mistake.
To establish whether her account was genuine, the health board investigated her access records and keystroke history and found her version of events “was not plausible” as on September 11, 2023 she had viewed blood test results and a number of other pages relating to the patient, for whom there was no record of her having issued a prescription.
Later investigations found that on the day she was notified of a formal investigation into her conduct she made a retrospective entry on the record of another patient, using the login details of a junior colleague for whom she was acting as supervising designated prescribing practitioner (DPP).
On December 18 and 19, 2023, she created and then modified a patient record entry for May 2019 using her own login, and then used her colleague’s access to create appointment entries for the second patient for July 2017 and December 2018 in an attempt to disguise her inappropriate access of the first patient’s medical records.
Having initially denied the allegations put to her by the health board, in her penultimate interview she said: “Maybe I did if that is what the evidence shows then, I must’ve done it. That's where I am at the moment.
“I think it's just a catalogue of one poor decision leading to more poor decisions. And I think once you go down that rabbit hole it's hard to get back out of it.”
In her final interview she said: “I just can’t explain it, it’s so out of character for me and maybe I’ve had a mini-breakdown.”
In a written statement provided to the FtP committee, Ms Clark said she has not worked as a pharmacist or in any other capacity since leaving the health board in May 2024, and now volunteers in a remote location.
In her statement she apologised to the health board where she had worked for 33 years “for betraying their trust,” and said working in HIV care was “a great honour” and “something I truly miss”.
She apologised to her colleague, saying she “abused my power as a senior pharmacist and the trust she had in me as a student” and that there was “no excuse” for her own behaviour. Ms Clark said she had tried to fulfil her duties as DPP notwithstanding the investigation and was “proud” her colleague had passed her assessments “amidst all of this”.
Ms Clark also apologised to the regulator for her actions and subsequent attempts to cover them up, which she described as “cowardly”. She said she would not oppose being removed from the register.
The FtP committee noted Ms Clark’s account that she had accessed the patient’s records at a time when he had health issues and needed an urgent referral to his GP and found that while she “ought to have used the proper channels,” this behaviour “may not have required regulatory action” had she owned up in the first instance.
However, she then went on to access the records on subsequent occasions and “went to some lengths to disguise what she had done,” said the committee, describing her “taking advantage” of her colleague as “a dereliction” of her leadership role.
The FtP committee said it considered the falsification of records to be “a very serious matter which posed a risk of harm,” commenting that patients “have a right to, and expect to have accurate medical records”.
Using a junior colleague’s login details “could have caused significant difficulties” for her and led to her being blamed for Ms Clark’s own actions, the committee added.
The committee found that while at present Ms Clark’s integrity “could not be relied upon,” her misconduct is capable of being remediated.
It said that has shown insight, fully acknowledged her misconduct and expressed “profound regret and remorse” but has not yet been able to articulate what has changed since the misconduct and what measures she has put in place to prevent a repetition of it.
Deciding against removal from the register as “disproportionate,” the FtP committee imposed a suspension “towards the upper end of the scale” to allow her to develop her insight and demonstrate how she might return to practise.
It also revoked an existing interim suspension order and imposed another temporary suspension during the 28-day appeal period.
Related: Warning for hospital pharmacist who viewed colleague’s medical records